Gedye and Sons



020 3427 5078

The Lakes

01539 532313

Thursday 4th February 2016

The Law Society propose ‘single test’ to diminish stamp duty fears

Clear instructions to your solicitor/conveyancer on any property purchase is crucial and even more so now following the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SLDT) changes which come into force from 1 April 2016.

In last year’s autumn statement and spending review, the government announced higher rates of SLDT on the purchase of additional residential properties as part of a ‘five-point’ plan to refocus housing support towards low-cost home ownership for first-time buyers.

In response The Law Society has now proposed a single test that seeks to resolve concerns arising from the government’s higher stamp duty rates for second homes. The three percent rise in SLDT rates will affect buy-to-let landlords (with fifteen or fewer properties) and second home purchasers.

In a direct response to HM Treasury’s consultation, the Law Society proposed a single test which could be applied at the point of purchase of an additional property. The test ‘would simply be whether the property is being purchased as the main residence for one of the joint purchasers’.

The government’s policy potentially penalises individuals who already have an investment property and now wish to buy a main residence. The Society’s argument centers around the proposal that married couples and civil partners should not be treated as a ‘single unit’ and it is the principle of independent taxation ‘dictates that you should look at the individual’s tax position’.

Given the rise in parental and family help towards first time buyers, the governments proposals could prove detrimental in scenarios where a parent wants to help children buy a main residence, The Law Society said it was better ‘to test the use to which the property is put rather than the formalities by which the parent invests’.

A proposed main residence replacement relief could cause problems in ‘chain-breaking’ situations, where a purchaser, let down by his buyer, ended up owning two properties and was then subject to an ‘upfront charge ‘of an additional three percent.

The Law Society went further to attack the governments proposals suggesting that eighteen months was too short a period between the sale of a previous main residence and purchase of a new main residence, making the point that whilst the housing market in London is particularly buoyant, this is not necessarily the case in other areas of the country. Further, the government’s proposals do not appear to consider the implications where a main residence is sold, and then a new one is being renovated or rebuilt.

The Society suggested a three-year period should be adopted, similar to other areas of SDLT such as in respect of claw back of higher threshold interests.

Issues identified by the Law Society extend to situations where given their role as tax collectors, the government requires UK conveyancers to report on, and make declarations on behalf of foreign purchasers, particularly in the ever growing London and Manchester property markets.

The problems identified by the Society include having regard to the difficulties faced by conveyancers in determining ‘foreign’ and ‘ownership’ by the purchaser and/or their spouse (treated as a single unit by the consultation proposal) as well as other family relatives and friends, foreign trusts and nominee arrangements, corporate ownership in which the foreign owner may have some interest and letters of wishes in respect of a portfolio of assets.

The Law Society went on to state it was ‘rather irrational’ to distinguish between overseas residential accommodation enjoyed by foreigners and overseas residential accommodation ‘owned’ by foreigners and further asked the government the basis for exempting purchasers who owned at least fifteen residential properties suggesting that the analysis done of the impact on the market was largely ‘a finger in the air’.

Identifying that ninety percent of residential transactions will not pay the higher rate of SLDT, the Law Society assumed that ‘the impact of a bulk-purchase test has been factored into that statistic’. The Law Society went further to say that the additional three percent charge should not apply to property traders, who ‘provide a useful function in providing liquidity in the market and improving the quality of housing stock, especially in relation to properties at the lower end of the market’.

The Law Society recognised that it is important that the taxpayer understands that they will be responsible for making their own application for reimbursement unless they separately instruct their solicitor/conveyance to act in this regard, and called for guidance in ‘plain English’ for lay people to accompany any changes.

How can Gedye & Sons help?

With a wealth of experience in all areas of property law and in particular off plan resales and assignments (where we act for many domestic and foreign investors and purchasers) our property team can advise on the legal implications of the governments SLDT changes on your purchase.

For an initial discussion as to how we maybe able to assist please contact Nick Davis in the first instance on 020 3427 5081 or

Download the full article

All news & events

Buying a newly built home

Once you have found that special place that you love; maybe its ideal for work / has that outside space you have been craving/ has room for a home office. Then the real fun begins!

Buying a new home off plan

It is common practice for developers to offer some or even all of the units on a development for sale long before construction work has finished. It can significantly reduce their borrowing costs but how does it affect you as a buyer?

Things to consider when buying a contract reassignment

I wrote an article a couple of years ago about off plan re- assignments and the interest generated since has prompted me to update that article and add some of the points that have come to light on transactions since.

The Law Society propose ‘single test’ to diminish stamp duty fears

Clear instructions to your solicitor/conveyancer on any property purchase is crucial and even more so now following the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SLDT) changes which come into force from 1 April 2016.

Mum, Dad, will you help me with my deposit please?

Buying your first property can be an exciting time, but it is also a huge investment. Most buyers will have saved hard for years on end just to fund their deposit

Buying an off plan re-sale apartment

Mark Jones, Director and Head of our Conveyancing department considers the risk to the unwary buyer.

Success for Solicitor who achieves Associate Membership of ACTAPS

We are very pleased to announce that Justin Roberts, Litigation Solicitor at Gedye & Sons has been accepted as an Associate Member of The Association of Contentious Trust and Probate Specialists (ACTAPS).

Gedye & Sons support “Will to Remember” Scheme

Alzheimer’s Society newest scheme ‘Will to Remember’ launched on Tuesday 27th May 2014 in the North West (Cumbria, Lancashire, Greater Manchester, Merseyside and Cheshire) in partnership with Solicitors for the Elderly.

Purchasing off plan re-sales presents challenges

Mark Jones as Head of our conveyancing department considers the potential risks of this increasingly popular phenomena.

FATCA legislation in operation by autumn 2014

Trusts, Trustees, Financial Institutions and Solicitors need to consider the new legislation. In this article Richard Roberts, Mark Jones and Sarah Murphy look at what it means and who it affects.

Blackwell House “Art Fund” evening

Gedye and Sons in association with Art Fund Cumbria are delighted to announce a reception and drinks evening at Blackwell House on Thursday 5th June 2014 from 5.30pm.

Gedye & Sons awarded with WIQS Accreditation.

Grange over Sands and Old Bailey based Gedye & Sons becomes one of the first twenty firms nationwide to obtain the Law Society’s new Wills and Inheritance Quality Scheme accreditation.

Historic Grange poster acquired by firm

Art lover and Gedye & Sons director Richard Roberts acquires historic LMS poster of Grange over Sands from Christie’s auction held in London.

Gedye & Sons Awarded WIQS Accreditation

The much published scheme which demonstrates an excellence in their field has seen the Law Society accredit the first group of law firms to its new Wills and Inheritance Quality Scheme (WIQS)

Richard Robert’s radio interview

Thursday 17th January 2012 saw Richard Roberts present a lecture at Clarke Willmott LLP in Bristol. This was as part of an evening sponsored by them for the Halycon network. Halycon is a professional network for the LGBT community.